Market Extra: Here’s why the stock market took the Trump tariff announcement so hard


Add trade tensions and the threat they pose to economic growth to the list of worries already dogging stock-market investors in 2018.

President Donald Trump’s announcement Thursday that he was set to impose tariffs on aluminum and steel imports sent stocks tumbling, with the Dow DJIA, -1.68%  ending the day down 420.22 points, or 1.7%, while the S&P 500 SPX, -1.33%  plunged 1.3%. Implied volatility, as measured by the Cboe Volatility Index VIX, +13.20% or VIX, jumped Thursday afternoon, ending the day around 13% higher at 22.47, after pushing above 25.

It’s the economy

The broad-based nature of the tariffs — and the broad-based market reaction — indicate that “investors are not only concerned about this particular action, but also how that’s going to affect the economy in the U.S.,” said James Norman, president of QS Investors, in a phone interview.

Read: These Dow and S&P 500 stocks took the biggest hits on fears of a Trump trade war

After all, not only did the news hit heavy users of steel and aluminum, like Boeing Co. BA, -3.46%  and Ford Motor Co. F, -3.02% , he noted, but other cyclically-sensitive areas, such as tech stocks, health care and consumer cyclicals.

Domestic U.S. steel prices were already up 20% since the beginning of the year in anticipation of possible tariffs, said Andrew Hunter, U.S. economist at Capital Economics, in a note. That’s a big potential drag on steel consumers in the machinery, motor vehicle and construction industries, he said, observing that the tariffs could, ironically, raise the incentive for those manufactures to move production offshore to avoid the tariffs.

More uncertainty means…

The threat of retaliation by trade partners is also a concern, potentially creating a spiral that could undercut global economic growth, widely seen as a key ingredient in the stock market’s 2017 rally.

See: Trump steel tariffs to hit these 8 countries the hardest (China is not one of them)

That was part of the “Goldilocks” backdrop for equities, along with subdued inflation pressures and confidence in the monetary policy outlook.

Over the past month, that’s been eroded by worries over a potential pickup in inflation and uncertainty over monetary policy.

…more volatility

“If you throw into that uncertainty about trade policy and how that might impact economic growth, then that increases uncertainty. And that’s why I think you’re seeing this volatility uptick,” Norman said.

Read: Here’s how stock market investors lost their ‘security blanket’

Meanwhile, there’s uncertainty over the fate of Gary Cohn, Trump’s top economic adviser. Politico reported that the tariff decision came after a frantic 24 hours in which Cohn and others tried to talk Trump out of taking action.

Stocks temporarily dipped in August amid speculation that Cohn would leave the White House in reaction to Trump’s remarks following deadly violence at a white-supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Va. Cohn’s potential departure could underline fears that economic policy would be dictated by nationalist advisers, economists said at the time.

Playing defense

Meanwhile, stocks continue to benefit from a positive economic backdrop, but investors should be prepared for a more normal volatility environment — and occasional volatility spikes — as they come to grips with the end of the ultralow volatility regime that prevailed until early February, Norman said.

Investors should probably lean away from more cyclical shares and toward a more defensive equity income strategy, he said, focusing on companies that have less volatile earnings, which can lead to more stable income production in terms of dividends.